
The first sitting of the final exams is over once again. Vmbo, havo and vwo pupils grappled with a range of topics, from brook lampreys to the evolution of giraffes, and from contraception to gene therapy. According to vmbo and havo teachers, the questions were manageable and pupils were in good spirits after the exam.
Vmbo-t
On 20 May, vmbo-t pupils sat their biology final exam, which for most of them was also their last exam of the season. Mark Moolhuijzen of Aeres vmbo Velp describes the exam as ‘surprising, enjoyable and varied’ – and that is clearly reflected in the topics covered. Through the lens of mine-detecting rats, contraception, tortoiseshell cats and gene therapy, a range of biological disciplines made an appearance. As in previous years, reading comprehension was once again an important skill to have mastered.
Even so, pupils flew through the first part of the exam. ‘The sting was in the tail,’ says Moolhuijzen. More challenging topics such as gene therapy, plants and genetics dominated the latter part of the exam. According to Moolhuijzen, pupils have always found plant questions more difficult because they find it harder to relate to them. In question 35, for example, pupils were asked to identify the pistil using an image of sea buckthorn (Hippophae rhamnoides) and indicate on which part of the plant fruits would develop – something many found tricky.
Nevertheless, pupils left the exam hall in relatively good spirits, and Moolhuijzen has not heard any strong criticism from his students. He himself considered it a relatively straightforward exam, with slightly too much reading comprehension and too little genuine biological reasoning. He was pleased, however, that after several years a question had returned in which pupils were required to draw a bar chart. In terms of topics, the exam was fairly comprehensive. The only thing Moolhuijzen felt was missing was a question on blood group determination.
Havo
Havo pupils also sat their biology exam on 20 May. As with the vmbo exam, reading comprehension was important for answering the questions. Jochem ‘t Hoen of the Ichthus College in Kampen’s initial impression is that the exam was not particularly difficult; pupils finished relatively quickly as a result. ‘t Hoen does feel that in terms of subject matter it was more of an exam for biologists than for havo pupils. ‘It’s good when the questions connect with pupils’ own world, but that was lacking in this exam.’ The questions did, however, align well with the curriculum and were therefore straightforward to prepare for.
A question about the brook lamprey stands out as a point of discussion for ‘t Hoen, and among pupils too. The question: the brook lamprey has an elongated, cylindrical body. Explain why this body shape is functional. The answer was expected to say something about how the brook lamprey’s shape allows it to move easily with the current. ‘But that is debatable for this species,’ ‘t Hoen notes. ‘Precisely because of the brook lamprey’s swimming motion, its surface area in the current is large, which makes it far from an ideal example.’
And that is not the only point on which ‘t Hoen has reservations. One of the topics in the exam is entitled ‘plant breeding for organic farming’, yet none of the questions under that topic actually concern plant breeding. ‘t Hoen also felt that systems thinking and evolutionary thinking were absent from the exam. Research skills, on the other hand, were well represented: hypothesis testing, designing an investigation and interpreting results all featured in the questions. These are areas ‘t Hoen always prepares his pupils for thoroughly. And so the havo pupils, too, left their biology exam in a generally positive mood.
