
Last autumn, the nature documentary Een gemeenschap van leven won the audience award at the Wildlife Film Festival Rotterdam, where the film had its premiere on 8 and 9 November. It received a score of 4.9 out of 5 – the highest score ever at the festival. A firm audience favourite, then. This is all the more striking given that the oak processionary moth, which plays a central role in the documentary, is generally not well liked at all. It would therefore be unfair to dismiss Een gemeenschap van leven as a film solely about the oak processionary moth.
The film is about far more: the oak as an ecosystem, and the relationship between humans and nature. The philosophical dimension is provided chiefly by eco-philosopher Matthijs Schouten, who in conversation with filmmaker Rik van der Linden, seated beside a majestic oak, reflects on different ways of seeing: from humanity as the crown of creation to a mystical relationship with nature. Towards the end of the film, Schouten argues for abolishing the word “nature” altogether – since it perpetuates an artificial distinction between humans and the natural world.
By supporting philosophical exchanges with stunning macro footage, or alternating them with matter-of-fact scenes – such as a land manager vacuuming caterpillar nests out of a tree – the documentary remains accessible rather than airy-fairy. The images invite reflection in a pleasingly concrete way. The pest controller embodies one view of the relationship between humans and nature; the entomologist, another.
It gradually becomes clear that all-out control of the oak processionary moth is a) pointless, and b) undesirable. Removing nests disrupts the ecosystem. Restoring balance to that system by encouraging natural predators appears to be more effective in the long run. And besides: who are we to decide that a caterpillar’s life is of secondary importance, simply because its urticating hairs can cause a nuisance? A nuisance that, it should be noted, has largely been created by humans themselves, by planting avenues of oaks that serve as motorways for the processionary moth – whilst such locations often provide no suitable habitat for the caterpillar’s natural enemies.
Learning to coexist with the oak processionary moth seems to be the message. Flemish researcher Kathleen Verstraete manages to generate sympathy for the caterpillar in the film. She takes home twigs bearing egg masses to follow the caterpillars’ life cycle. Fear, she says, is unnecessary: the caterpillars only develop urticating hairs after their third moult, and until then they can be studied safely. Naturalis entomologist Aglaia Bouma also speaks in the documentary with great affection and fascination about all the insects that live on oak trees.
Yet the film inspires the greatest sense of wonder through its macro footage of caterpillars hatching, stag beetles fighting, and moths laying eggs. It brings home just how vividly an oak tree can harbour an entire community of life. The question that remains is whether humans want to be part of that community, or would rather see themselves as separate from it. That opinions on this differ becomes painfully apparent in the film’s closing sequence: a vehicle spraying biological pesticides in a wide arc over oak trees, rendering life impossible for caterpillars of every species.

Een gemeenschap van leven
Director: Rik van der Linden
Watch at tinyurl.com/eengemeenschapvanleven or see tinyurl.com/filmvertoningen for public screenings.
