
Rising temperatures are causing the earliest plants to flower ever sooner. Butterflies and moths that visit flowers are not keeping pace. The question is whether this will have serious consequences.
The overlap between the flowering period of plants and the flight season of flower-visiting butterflies and moths in Europe is shrinking as a result of climate change. Since 2000, that overlap has shortened by around eight days. This is reported by a team of Chinese and European researchers in Proceedings of the Royal Society B on 4 November. The reduction is driven by the earliest individual plants coming into flower progressively sooner. Butterflies and moths are also shifting earlier, but less rapidly.
For this study, the team drew data from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility on more than seven hundred species of flowering plants (Angiospermae) and more than six hundred species of butterflies and moths (Lepidoptera) that visit plants to drink nectar and in doing so pollinate the flowers. The researchers scored observations from Europe of flowering plants and adult insects over the period 2000–2024. The benchmarks per species per year were the dates by which 10 per cent, 50 per cent, and 90 per cent of that year’s observations of a species had been recorded.
Earlier flowering
Averaged across plant species, the earliest individuals came into flower half a day per year sooner – amounting to twelve days over the full study period. The date by which half of a species’ observations had been recorded shifted forward by the same amount, whilst late-flowering individuals showed no advancement. The window during which flowers are present has therefore grown longer.
Butterflies and moths also shifted earlier, but on average by less – four days over the entire study period. For them, the shift was equal across all three benchmarks. The number of days on which both flowers and butterflies or moths were recorded declined by 0.34 days per year as a result of the difference in advancement between flowers and insects. By 2024, the overlap was eight days shorter than in 2000.
The cause of the earlier timing is climate warming, to which both plants and insects are sensitive. In plants, early individuals respond more strongly to rising temperatures than late-flowering members of the same species, which explains the observed pattern.
More serious problems
There is thus a growing mismatch between plants and the butterflies and moths that pollinate them, the researchers write. This could, they argue, have far-reaching consequences for pollination networks, food webs, and ecosystems.
‘I’m not entirely convinced by that’, says Chris van Swaay, project manager at De Vlinderstichting (the Dutch Butterfly Conservation). ‘The research is probably sound and the results are consistent with what we know. But the reduction in overlap is quite small, and the consequences for both plants and butterflies are likely to be modest.’
‘A more serious problem for butterflies than this slightly earlier flowering is that there are fewer nectar plants than there used to be, partly due to agriculture and nitrogen surpluses’, he says. ‘That genuinely threatens butterflies. Climate change is most threatening because species have to shift their ranges. That breaks down when the ranges of interdependent species start to diverge, or when cold-loving species run up against the northern edge of the continent.’
