Hannibal’s most efficient Alpine route ran via the Col de la Traversette

Deel

An elephant climbs a rock. Credit: Frank af Petersens_Save the Elephants

The most energy-efficient route for Hannibal to cross the Alps with his army was via the Col de la Traversette. That is the conclusion reached by ecologists on 6 July in PNAS. Hannibal made his Alpine crossing in 218 BC, on his way to Rome. The exact route he took remains unknown.


To cross the Alps in fifteen days with 46,000 men, 7,000 horses and 37 elephants, Hannibal’s army expended a total of at least 5.42 terajoules of energy, as calculations based on various models show. That figure applies to the most efficient route; had Hannibal chosen the Col du Clapier, for instance, the cost would have been 6.28 terajoules. It must have been impossible on any route to replenish all of that energy through food alone. The elephants in particular would have had to graze more or less continuously.


This means the army drew on its fat reserves: men lost around 19 per cent of their reserves during the crossing via the Col de la Traversette, horses 11 per cent. Elephants are reasonably robust and shed only 4 per cent of their fat reserves. This may explain why losses were greatest among the troops, whilst almost all of the elephants initially survived the Alpine journey.


Whether Hannibal actually chose the route via the Col de la Traversette remains uncertain; it is also an open question whether the general could accurately judge that this was the most energy-efficient path.

Read now also