Is the Netherlands running short of plant taxonomists?

Deel

Page from the herbarium of the German botanist Hieronymus Harder (1523–1607). Credit: Wikipedia


A recent publication in Trends in Plant Science (2025) warns of a global shortage of plant taxonomists, including in the Netherlands. Is the lack of taxonomic expertise a cause for concern?


Is the Netherlands running short of plant taxonomists?
‘The shortage of plant taxonomists – experts who identify and systematically classify plant species on the basis of specific characteristics – is a reality, in the Netherlands and beyond’, says systems biologist Eric Schranz of Wageningen University & Research. ‘The number of taxonomists has been declining worldwide for many years. I cannot say exactly how many taxonomists the Netherlands has, but it would not surprise me if the figure is indeed fewer than ten, as the authors claim in Trends in Plant Science. Of course, that number also depends strongly on how narrowly one defines the term “taxonomist”.’


Why are experts in this field so scarce?
Although the article argues that insufficient structured training and mentorship for young taxonomists are often at the root of the problem, Schranz does not recognise this within the Netherlands. ‘Here we have the luxury of having all the resources we need. In Wageningen, all first-year biology students learn to identify native plants and insects. Later, they can opt for a field course abroad focused on biodiversity recognition, and for an advanced module in which they learn how to construct phylogenetic trees. I know that the fundamentals of taxonomy also form part of the curriculum at some other Dutch universities’, he says. Schranz points to research funding as a possible cause of the plant taxonomist shortage – the way in which publications in one field are pushed to the fore whilst those in another are sidelined. Given the fundamental nature of taxonomy, he argues, it is difficult to compete for grants against other branches of biology.


Are taxonomists still relevant today?
Although academia now places less value on taxonomy as a standalone discipline, the core skills of the field remain absolutely relevant, according to Schranz. He considers its potentially dusty image undeserved. Even in his own research projects – in which his team, for example, works through complex genera in detail to improve the cultivation of a particular crop belonging to that genus – close collaboration with a taxonomist remains central. ‘Not taxonomy for taxonomy’s sake, but as a means of answering larger-scale questions’, he says.


Can technology replace taxonomic expertise?
‘It can’, Schranz suspects, ‘if we want it to.’ To some extent, this is already happening. AI image recognition can often correctly identify species on the basis of morphological patterns, and DNA analyses can reveal cryptic species and link plant stages that look quite different from one another. At present, however, new species or aberrant specimens are difficult for AI to handle, and DNA research does not automatically distinguish between species and subspecies. Schranz: ‘Taxonomists make judgement calls based on small variations and details, such as minute reproductive structures. That is enormously valuable. When we sort and organise with care, it also deepens our connection with the nature around us – fostering a far deeper appreciation than we get from quickly snapping a photo with an app on our phone.’


How can plant taxonomy become fashionable again?
In the Netherlands, enthusiasm for species identification is not lacking, as evidenced by the enormous number of observations submitted annually through citizen science platforms. ‘The Netherlands is truly unique in that respect: when a new animal or plant species turns up, the news spreads like wildfire’, says Schranz. ‘Many taxonomists have had an enormous passion for a particular group of species since childhood’, he continues. ‘I see that in current students too, but the jobs simply are not there for the taking. Taxonomy as a toolkit for answering weighty questions is, I think, the solution. The leading figures in plant taxonomy are truly irreplaceable, but in this way one can hope that dedicated biologists will follow in their footsteps when they unfortunately retire or move on.’

Read now also