
Dutch grasslands and woodlands yield fewer plant species for comparable sampling efforts than they did in the past. This also puts pressure on the idea that designating additional nature reserves will automatically safeguard sufficient biodiversity.
Anyone surveying the same area of grassland or woodland in the Netherlands today as half a century ago will find, on average, fewer plant species. This is not only because species are disappearing, but also because vegetation communities have grown more similar to one another. Dutch grasslands and woodlands have consequently become both poorer and more homogeneous, conclude Kaixuan Pan of Naturalis and colleagues from Leiden University and the Netherlands Institute of Ecology (NIOO-KNAW) in Ecology Letters of 15 June.
Native vascular plants
The researchers draw on the Dutch Vegetation Database, which contains more than six hundred thousand vegetation relevés from the period 1930 to 2017. These cover sample plots distributed across the Netherlands in which native vascular plants were recorded. Pan divided the data into three periods: 1930–1959, 1960–1989, and 1990–2017. He then constructed so-called species accumulation curves: graphs showing how many species are added as researchers sample a greater area.
‘The relationship between area and biodiversity is regarded as one of the best-known laws in ecology. But that relationship has changed’, Pan explains. ‘In the past, sampling the same area would quickly turn up more species. Nowadays you find fewer species, and the habitats across the landscape have grown more similar to one another.’
Spatial variation
This pattern does not simply mean that every individual plot has lost the same number of species. The analysis also captures spatial variation: if different sites contain the same common species, additional searching yields fewer new ones. In ecological terms, this points to a decline in beta diversity – the differences in species composition between locations. According to the researchers, this is consistent with a loss of habitat quality and with homogenisation, whereby specialists lose ground and generalists become relatively more important.
The greatest losses occur after the first measurement period. This coincides with large-scale agricultural intensification, the loss of semi-natural grasslands, and sharply rising nitrogen deposition in the second half of the twentieth century. The study cannot demonstrate these causes at the level of individual plots, but the timing is consistent with well-documented changes in the Dutch landscape.
Under pressure
Striking is the difference between grasslands and woodlands. Grasslands show some degree of recovery after the steep decline, although species richness remains below its historical level. Woodlands show no recovery: even in the most recent period, researchers find fewer species for comparable sampling efforts. Pan considers this difference plausible, because grasslands are dominated by short-lived species that can respond more rapidly to management and restoration measures. ‘Woodlands, however, are composed of many long-lived species and develop slowly. As a result, the consequences of historical degradation can persist for decades, whilst recovery also takes a great deal of time.’
Protected areas offer no complete immunity either. In protected grasslands, species richness remains relatively stable, but in protected woodlands the decline continues. This surprised Pan. ‘Protected areas are essential for retaining biodiversity, but they are not sufficient to halt biodiversity loss’, he says. Protected nature does not exist as an island isolated from its surroundings: nitrogen deposition, desiccation, climate change, and land use in the areas around nature reserves all make their effects felt within the boundaries.
An opportunity to reverse biodiversity loss
In this respect, the study touches on the international target of protecting at least 30 per cent of land and sea by 2030. According to Pan, expanding protected areas remains important, but is insufficient on its own. Outside nature reserves too, restoration, better management, and a reduction of pressures are needed. ‘We have a real opportunity to reverse biodiversity loss’, he says, ‘but to achieve that we must combine effective nature conservation with restoration and a reduction of existing pressures.’
