
Where ecologists previously focused mainly on threatened species in protected nature reserves, attention is increasingly turning to common species in towns and countryside. ‘Baseline nature quality’ is the new buzzword.
The approaching biodiversity week will probably have rather less to say about rare species and Natura 2000 sites. Conservation organisations and ecologists have broadened their gaze to encompass urban areas and agricultural land. The populations of ‘common’ species are also in widespread decline โ a fact confirmed once again by the new Red List of Dragonflies published at the end of April. Reversing this trend requires raising the quality of the landscape, together with its associated species, everywhere. In other words: ensuring a baseline nature quality (BNQ). The term was introduced eight years ago by Robert Kwak of Vogelbescherming Nederland (BirdLife Netherlands) and has since been embraced by the species organisations and by the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries, Food Security and Nature (LVVN).
Since 2024, the ministry-funded Knowledge Programme on Baseline Nature Quality has been under way: a consortium of SoortenNL, Vogelbescherming, Deltaplan Biodiversiteitsherstel, IUCN, Naturalis and Wageningen University is working to strengthen the scientific basis of the concept and to give practical shape to its implementation and monitoring.
The core of BNQ is steering by conditions rather than by species or habitat types. ‘The aim is for conditions everywhere to reach a level at which they contribute to suitable habitat’, says programme leader Floor Edixhoven of Deltaplan Biodiversiteitsherstel. ‘For each type of landscape we have made very concrete what conditions you want there, and also what “good” looks like. In built-up areas that means a certain percentage of unpaved surface, but you also want enough shrubs and trees, and wildlife-friendly banks. Then there are environmental factors such as nutrient levels and pollution. And management is a determining factor too.’ These conditions are differentiated by landscape type. ‘If we did the same thing everywhere, the whole of the Netherlands could end up looking identical’, says Edixhoven. ‘A dune and coastal landscape is very different from the hill country of South Limburg. You want to steer towards conditions that suit that particular area.’
Indicator species
The new approach does not focus solely on conditions โ specific species are very much part of the picture. ‘Those species are ultimately the proof of the pudding’, says Michiel Wallis de Vries, who is involved in the knowledge programme on behalf of De Vlinderstichting (the Dutch Butterfly Conservation). ‘If, despite improvements in conditions, characteristic species of that landscape fail to return, we need to take a closer look at how the system works and whether we are taking the right measures. Ultimately it must become a continuous cycle of doing, learning, and doing better.’
Wallis de Vries is working, among other things, on the selection of indicator species for BNQ. To select the approximately five hundred species in total, species distribution models have been used, supplemented by expert judgement where data are insufficient. In addition to being characteristic of particular landscapes and indicative of the relevant conditions, a species must also be readily monitored by volunteers. ‘If you want to monitor across the whole country, you need a great many people and cannot do without volunteer recorders. Epiphytic lichens are highly indicative of ammonia concentrations in the air, but species that can only be identified by specialists have been excluded from consideration.’
Other knowledge gaps in the project are also being addressed, so that the concept can genuinely be put into practice. One of these concerns the minimum population size needed for sustainable presence within a landscape unit. Wallis de Vries: ‘Whether a neighbourhood or a given landscape has sufficient scale for those species to occur there โ we still need to underpin that properly. In the meantime, there is no need to wait. Pilot projects in both urban and rural areas are already working on baseline quality. We are learning a great deal from those too.’
To support implementation, Deltaplan is developing the Natuur Navigator: a publicly accessible digital tool that visualises the current state of BNQ conditions for any selected area. Edixhoven: ‘You simply select an area โ a municipality, a neighbourhood, or whatever. You get a kind of baseline measurement showing the state of those conditions. Alongside that, you are offered a set of measures. These remain measures at a broad level, because you always need to look locally at where the pressures are coming from. But it does provide an initial steer.’

Risk
The question arises whether the broad focus on common species outside nature reserves will lead to less attention and funding for ‘real’ nature within those reserves. Wallis de Vries turns the argument on its head: ‘I don’t think that will be the case’, he responds. ‘It isn’t a matter of one or the other โ they reinforce each other. If that baseline quality is achieved in the areas surrounding nature reserves, it also becomes considerably easier to maintain quality within those reserves. I am also involved in an OBN project on the design of transition zones around Natura 2000 sites. There we look at what needs to happen outside those areas in order to meet the targets within them. Sometimes those targets can only be met because something changes in the surrounding landscape. And if you have already achieved those baseline quality conditions, you are already a good deal closer to the goal.‘
Edixhoven, by contrast, sees a different risk: ‘If we start steering towards baseline nature quality, how do we ensure we don’t get stuck there? The danger is that we end up doing only the bare minimum that is required. That is something we as nature conservationists need to remain sharply aware of.’
The knowledge programme runs until 2028, but is already delivering a number of concrete outputs at this stage. On 21 April, a report on BNQ in policy was published (see box). Following the earlier handbook on BNQ in the built environment earlier this year, a handbook for the rural landscape โ including verges, farmyards and small woodlands โ will follow in June. This will be accompanied by a monitoring handbook, with a step-by-step approach for each species group.’
Before the project concludes, a great deal of practical experience still needs to be gained. Edixhoven: ‘We are not only trying to develop knowledge, but also to ensure that municipalities and authorities can genuinely get to work with baseline nature quality. There is still much to come: the handbook for area-based processes, the Natuur Navigator, the monitoring methods. We are doing our best to ensure it also takes root in practice.’
Frontrunners
In practice, it is primarily provinces, water authorities and municipalities that should play a major role in developing baseline nature quality. That point has not yet been reached, but some have already taken the first steps in this direction. The Province of Drenthe, for instance, published its Handreiking basiskwaliteit natuur last year, in which the concept is presented as an ecological baseline standard to be applied. This is made concrete through practical examples of nature-inclusive design of infrastructure, the ecologically minded management of verges and waterways, and the deployment of area-based measures in the rural landscape. A growing number of municipalities is also working on it. One of the frontrunners is the municipality of Ede, which has set itself the goal of having baseline quality in order by 2030.
The Netherlands must work on baseline quality
It is hardly surprising that the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries, Food Security and Nature has embraced the concept of baseline nature quality, given existing and forthcoming legislation. The European Birds and Habitats Directives, among others, oblige member states to care for all bird species, including those outside nature reserves. But experts from IUCN Netherlands conclude in the report Basiskwaliteit Natuur in beleid, published at the end of April, that the conservation targets for species within Natura 2000 sites can in practice only be met if baseline quality in the surrounding landscape is also in order. Article 10 of the Habitats Directive furthermore obliges member states to actively manage landscape elements that support migration and genetic exchange.
The Water Framework Directive also compels the Netherlands to improve water-related conditions. The Netherlands should have achieved good ecological and chemical water quality everywhere by 2027 โ a target that is widely assumed will not be met. In any case, those targets cannot be achieved through measures within the water body alone; adjustments to the surrounding land use are unavoidable. Buffer strips, extensification and hydrological restoration are simultaneously Water Framework Directive measures and building blocks for baseline nature quality.

An potentially even greater influence is exerted by the Nature Restoration Law. This European legislation โ which explicitly requires work on nature restoration outside existing nature reserves โ was adopted in 2024, and this year the Netherlands must demonstrate in a nature restoration plan how the stated targets will be met. And those targets are substantial: by 2030, member states must implement restoration measures on 30 per cent of habitats in poor condition, rising to 90 per cent by 2050. Deterioration must be prevented and ecological coherence strengthened. Because a large proportion of the restoration need lies outside protected areas, working towards baseline nature quality is indispensable for achieving these goals.
