Unusual mass die-off of Adélie penguins was not caused by bird flu

Deel

Adélie penguins at Heroina Island, with the Australis in the background. Photo: Alice Reade

In the Antarctic summer of 2023/2024, Adélie penguins did not die en masse from bird flu, but from avian cholera.


At the end of 2023, bird flu was detected in Antarctica. An international team of researchers responded by organising an expedition. In March 2024, they sailed for several weeks to ten different locations in Antarctica. On Heroina Island and Beagle Island, part of the Danger Islands, they found hundreds of dead Adélie penguins. It turned out that bird flu was not to blame.


For birds in Antarctica, H5N1 – the highly pathogenic strain of bird flu – was a new pathogen, explains Matteo Iervolino. The researcher from Erasmus MC sailed on the Australis expedition. The virus caused high mortality among several skua species on Beak Island, including the subantarctic skua. The researchers established this from samples analysed in their mobile laboratory on board the ship.

Adélie penguins on Heroina Island. Photo: Alice Reade


Hundreds of carcasses
A few days later, the expedition went ashore on the Danger Islands. ‘Heroina Island is home to the third largest colony of Adélie penguins in the world’, says Iervolino. The colony on Beagle Island ranks fourth. But in a small part of the breeding site, the researchers had already counted 532 frozen carcasses. ‘We immediately thought of bird flu.’


The virologists took samples from 49 dead penguins for molecular analysis. ‘We also had pathologists on board’, Iervolino adds. From nine dead birds, they collected tissue samples for virological and microscopic examination. The results surprised the researchers. RNA analysis detected bird flu in only a handful of penguins, and it was not certain whether the subtype was H5N1. Something else was going on here.


‘There are not many diseases that can cause such large-scale mortality in Antarctica’, says Iervolino. The researchers delved into the literature and identified avian cholera as a possible explanation. In the mobile laboratory on board the Australis they were unable to confirm this disease, but back in Rotterdam, DNA from the bacterium Pasteurella multocida proved to be present in 46 of the 49 sampled birds, as they report on 14 October in Proceedings of the Royal Society B. That is the bacterium that causes avian cholera. Pathological examination confirmed the diagnosis, Iervolino continues.


All organs affected
The disease often begins with a respiratory infection, Iervolino explains. ‘But the bacterium enters the birds’ bloodstream and quickly reaches other organs.’ The birds can die within a day. The researchers also observed a sick seal. They took samples from the mucus the animal had left on the rocks. These too tested positive for DNA from Pasteurella multocida, as well as for bird flu. Which pathogen poses the greater threat to this animal cannot be determined.


The study underlines the importance of monitoring a broader range of pathogens in Antarctica, not just H5N1, says Iervolino. Avian cholera was already detected on the continent in the 1990s, but no one is monitoring the disease. For birds and mammals in Antarctica, it can have major consequences – on top of the effects of bird flu, climate change, and the industrial fishing fleets in Antarctic waters.

Read now also