
Molecules that ‘want’ to move, water that ‘wants to go somewhere’: anyone who discusses diffusion and osmosis in the classroom quickly runs up against stubborn misconceptions. A subject-didactics study shows how those misconceptions can be broken down.
‘Water wants to move towards salt.’ It sounds logical, but biologically it is wrong. Yet this is precisely how many Year 10 pupils explain osmosis, as Quincy Silanoe noticed during her teaching placement at the Minkema College in Woerden. ‘And when it comes to equilibrium, they think everything stops. As if molecules are taking a break.’
Stumbling blocks
Those persistent ideas formed the starting point for her subject-didactics design study at the teacher-training programme of Utrecht University, where students in their final year develop and evaluate an intervention in their own teaching practice. Diffusion and osmosis are notorious stumbling blocks in upper secondary education: abstract and difficult to connect to what pupils can actually observe. ‘You can’t see those molecules moving randomly. So pupils fill in the gaps themselves.’
Three stations
In her study, Silanoe took her pupils on a ‘journey through three stations’. First the basics: text, figures and diagrams from the textbook. This was followed by animations, simulations and a role-play practical in which pupils act out particle movement themselves. Finally, two practicals – a shrinking mushroom and plasmolysis in red onion cells – to bridge the gap from micro to macro.
Before and after the intervention, she presented pupils with two-tier multiple-choice questions. The percentage of correct answers rose from 28 to 87 per cent. The number of misconceptions fell sharply in particular after the second station. ‘In those animations they can see that molecules keep moving even at equilibrium. That suddenly makes it tangible.’
Not everything proved easy to correct, however. Many pupils continue to reason in terms of salt or sugar rather than water concentration. ‘Water is seen as something passive, a kind of carrier. That is a stubborn idea.’
Micro–macro connection
Silanoe found it striking that the practical work alone did not automatically lead to deeper understanding. ‘As a teacher you really have to stay on top of that micro–macro connection, with targeted thinking questions.’ Pupils said afterwards that ‘the penny only dropped’ when different teaching approaches came together.
The extra time such an approach requires, Silanoe sees as an investment. ‘If you tackle this properly once at the start of upper secondary, you need to return to it less often later on.’ Diffusion and osmosis thus prove to be not only core biological concepts, but also a lesson in didactics: making misconceptions visible is the first step to genuinely breaking them down.
Interested in the teaching materials based on this study? Visit: tinyurl.com/osmosereis
